Michigan Court of Appeals September 26, 1972, Docket No. 9643 (State Highway Commission v. Wright)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-09-1972

R. B. Burns, J.

On November 5, 1969, a jury trial was commenced to determine the amount of compensation to be awarded to defendant for the taking by plaintiff of a parcel of land owned by defendant. The primary issue contested at that trial was the suitability of defendant’s land for development as a regional shopping center.

Two real estate appraisers hired by plaintiff testified, respectively, that the parcel had a value of $422,000 and $445,000. Both appraisals were based upon values received in comparable sales of land in the area. Neither appraiser considered sales of land for development as regional shopping centers to be comparable sales. An expert economic consultant, one John W. Green, testified that, in his opinion, the site was not suitable for a regional shopping center. Green’s opinion was based upon two conclusions: (a) the projected purchasing power of Genesee County was not adequate to support another regional shopping center, and (b) no major retailer was willing to establish in the Flint area a department store of the type necessary to anchor a regional shopping center. The former conclusion was derived from data compiled by the Bureau of the Census. The latter conclusion was based upon Green’s own inquiries *662to several retailers. Green testified specifically to conversations with one Norman A. Menz, an employee of J. C. Penney Company, Inc.

Several witnesses testified for defendant that the parcel was suitable for development as a regional shopping center and, as such, had a value between $1,490,500 and $1,653,235.

On November 19th counsel for defendant informed the trial court that Menz denied having any conversations with Green. Counsel requested a continuance to allow production of Menz as a witness. Menz was employed in Penney’s New York office. The request was denied. On November 20th the case was submitted to the jury.

The jury returned a verdict for $445,000.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.