Supreme Court of New Hampshire November 3, 1972, No. 6406 (Brouillard v. Saunders Bros.)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-11-1972
Grimes, J.
This is an appeal from a plaintiff’s jury verdict in an action brought to recover for the death of Edward L. Sharon resulting from a log rolling off a truck. The issues raised by defendant’s exceptions and transferred by Keller, C.J., are whether Sharon was contributorily negligent as a matter of law and whether the trial court erred in not submitting to the jury the question whether Sharon was contributorily negligent for loading the truck in excess of the weight per*390mitted by RSA 263:61 (VIII) (a). We decide these issues in the negative and sustain the verdict.
Edward L. Sharon was a logging contractor who had agreed to sell logs to the defendant. It was his responsibility to load the logs on defendant’s flatbed trailers which would be left at the logging site and when loaded would be hauled away by truck tractors operated by defendant’s employees.
On December 27, 1966, Sharon or one of his employees loaded a trailer. It was loaded above the stakes on the driver’s side. That afternoon, defendant’s driver Dow arrived with a tractor and an empty flatbed. He left the flatbed at the town road and proceeded with the tractor over Sharon’s logging road to the logging site about a quarter of a mile away. On arrival, he attached the loaded trailer to the tractor. The trailer was loaded with two tiers of logs. RSA 263:68 prohibits the operation on the highways of this State of a motor truck trailer loaded as this one was unless each tier of logs is bound by three chains of three-eighths inch wire properly spaced to secure the load. Dow had left his six chains on the empty trailer at the town road and had no chains to bind the load at the logging site.
One Thomas, an employee of Sharon’s, asked Dow how he expected to get out without chains. Dow shrugged and Sharon suggested that Thomas give him two of his chains. Thomas removed the center chains from a load he had ready to be moved which had been secured with three chains for each of two tiers.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit