Supreme Court of Puerto Rico February 29, 1972, No. CR-70-75 (People v. Morales Romero)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-02-1972

Mr. Justice Martín

delivered the opinion of the Court.

The prosecuting attorney filed a complaint against appellant herein for the offense of grand larceny. He was charged that on May 3, 1969, while Felicita Hernández Estrella was waiting for a change of light at Providencia Street, in San-turce, he took from the automobile she was driving a ladies handbag which contained jewels valued at more than $100 and the amount of three hundred thirty-seven dollars belonging to Mrs. Estrella.

Three days after the events which gave rise to appellant’s conviction, and without any information having been filed against him, the prejudiced party identified appellant as the perpetrator of the facts, from among seven or eight photographs which were shown to her. Moments later she personally identified him in a lineup where there were “five or six youngsters.”

At the hearing of the case appellant waived his right to be tried by a jury. The court accepted his waiver. The evidence having been presented, the court found defendant guilty and sentenced him to serve an indeterminate sentence of from three to six years in the penitentiary.

*436h — i

The first error assigned is that the judgment rendered is null and void because the defendant did not waive his right to trial by jury in an express and intelligent manner.

The assignment lacks merit. Appellant accepts that the trial judge extensively explained to him the difference between a trial by jury and a trial by the court without a jury. In addition, the judge asked him several questions to make sure of the voluntariness of the waiver.1

*437There is no doubt that the waiver of the right to a trial by jury should be made by the defendant voluntarily and intelligently. People v. Juarbe de la Rosa, 95 P.R.R. 736 (1968). See, also, People v. Delgado Martínez, 96 P.R.R. 703 (1968); People v. Colón Báez, 96 P.R.R. 618 (1968). That notwithstanding, our decision in the Juarbe de la Rosa case is not applicable to the case at bar.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.