United States Court of Military Appeals May 19, 1972, No. 24,721 (United States v. Pettingill)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-05-1972

Opinion of the Court

Quinn, Judge:

Two issues are presented by this appeal. The first is whether the evidence is sufficient to support the accused’s conviction by general court-martial of dishonorable failure to pay a debt; the second is whether the United States Army Court of Military Review correctly denied a petition for new trial alleging, in part, that the Government willfully suppressed material evidence favorable to the accused.

The incident, which began the chain of events that led to two charges against the accused, one of which was dismissed at trial for lack of evidence, arose in July 1968, on Okinawa. Captain Knarr, an Air Force officer, occupied a civilian house, with his family, in the Ojana Heights area, which he had purchased in May 1966 on arrival in Okinawa. It further appears that ownership of the house was separate from ownership of the land but carried with it a form of leasehold interest in the land. Sometime before July 1968, Captain Knarr was scheduled to return to the United States, with the departure date set for July 29. Accordingly, he put the house up for sale. “A few days” previous to that, “an Okinawan” from “the bank” appeared at the house and advised the captain that the premises “had a mortgage on it.” The captain and his wife went to the office of Bei Ryu Housing Corporation and spoke to a Mr. Shinjo. Apparently the housing corporation was the developer and builder of the houses in the area. Mr. Shinjo confirmed that a mortgage lien for construction funds was on the premises, but “assured” the captain it would be removed.

In the first week of July, the accused initiated negotiations for purchase of the house. These resulted in an oral agreement of purchase of the house and certain property, such as an air conditioner, a refrigerator, and “items like that” for $7,000.00.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.