Court of Appeals of Oregon June 18, 1973, C-72-03-0994 (State v. Willingham)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-06-1973
PER CURIAM.
The state appeals from an order dismissing a second degree assault indictment against defendant. The assault allegedly occurred on March 4, 1972, indictment was returned on March 22, and arrest war
*505
rant concurrently issued. Defendant was arrested on October 6, 1972, never having previously known that he was charged with anything, although a policeman had talked with him on the night of the incident. The police had defendant’s address at all times. No excuse is given for the six-and-one-half-month delay in serving the warrant. It was attributable to pure negligence.
After hearing evidence on defendant’s motion to dismiss for lack of speedy trial, the judge said:
“* * * I think any delay at all beyond the usual length of time we attempt to dispose of cases, tends to impair * * *. In this particular case * * * there is unexplained, unnecessary delay. It is, I think, prejudicial * *
In the formal written findings and conclusions he said:
“"While defendant showed no substantial actual prejudice * * * and while the length of the delay * * i! was not so prolonged as to permit a legal presumption of prejudice to the defendant’s defense * * *”
the failures of the state caused an unreasonable delay calling for the dismissal.
In
Barker v. Wingo,
407 US 514, 92 S Ct 2182, 33 L Ed 2d 101 (1972), factors to consider in determining whether delays by prosecution violate speedy trial requirements were set out. The court noted that while intentional delay calculated to prejudice a defense would weigh heavily against the prosecution, that negligence not culpable in nature should nevertheless also be considered. 407 US at 531.
See also State v. Serrell,
265 Or 216, 507 P2d 1405 (1973).
The trial court did find defendant was prejudiced, albeit not seriously, in the case at bar. Dis
*506
missal is a drastic prophylactic and to he used only sparingly.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit