Michigan Supreme Court December 18, 1973, 2 June Term 1973, Docket No. 54,447 (State Bar Grievance Administrator v. Sauer)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-12-1973

Williams, J.

This case concerns two issues arising from Rule 16.17 of the Michigan Supreme Court Rules for the State Bar Grievance Board.

*452

Issue 1 is the same issue recently before this Court in

State Bar Grievance Administrator v Lewis,

389 Mich 668; 209 NW2d 203 (1973), namely what kind of procedure must the State Bar Grievance Board pursue under Rule 16.17 in a discipline case based on an attorney’s conviction of a crime.

Issue 2 is novel to the instant case, whether the State Bar Grievance Board may impose a penalty upon respondent under Rule 16.17 after a trial court conviction but before respondent has exhausted all of his appeal possibilities.

I —FACTS

On August 14, 1972 respondent, in a bench trial in the Western Federal District of Michigan, was found guilty of three counts and not guilty of three counts of a six count indictment for false income tax returns. On the same day he was sentenced to concurrent terms of one year imprisonment on each count. Respondent has appealed that conviction and was granted stay of sentence pending appeal.

Thereafter, on August 29, 1972, respondent was ordered to appear before the State Bar Grievance Board on September 22, 1972 to show cause why -he should not be disciplined under Rule 16.17 because of his Federal conviction. Respondent answered, pleading (1) that the Federal judge had found that "[t]he witnesses testifying to character and veracity were impressive;” (2) that the Federal judge further observed that "there was no evidence * * * Sauer was guilty of sharp or dishonest practices”; and (3) that there was no final resolution of guilt or innocence, thus the State Bar Grievance Board’s action was premature and a deprivation of respondent’s property without due

*453

process of law. After hearing on the order to show cause, the State Bar Grievance Board found the respondent fell within the provisions of Rule 15, § 2(5) and Rule 16.17 and was therefore subject to discipline.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.