Supreme Court of Minnesota December 7, 1973, 43923 (Arens v. Minneapolis-Moline, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-12-1973

Per Curiam.

Appeal from a judgment entered pursuant to an order granting defendant’s motion for dismissal for failure to establish a prima facie case and from an order denying a new trial. We affirm.

This action was brought against Minneapolis-Moline, Inc., to recover for the wrongful death of Alphonse Arens, who was killed as a result of a tractor accident. Decedent’s death occurred while working with a eoemployee of the county in removing large rocks from a county road ditch with the aid of a four-wheel-tractor loader equipped with a front-end scoop.

Immediately preceding the accident, the tractor decedent was operating became stuck in the road ditch. In order to pull the tractor out of the ditch, a chain was connected between the front end of the tractor and the back of a truck. Decedent remained on the tractor as his coworker began to pull with the truck. While in the truck, the coworker could not see the decedent or the tractor. After he felt several jerks, the coworker left the truck to see what had happened and noticed that the right front wheel of the tractor had broken off at the steering knuckle. The wheel was lying at the point where the tractor had been stuck. The tractor had been moved several feet from its original position and was

*522

standing upright. Decedent was lying between these two spots and had died of a crushing injury. There was an impression of 4 or 5 inches in the ground adjacent to the right front wheel. The only damage to the tractor was the loss of the wheel.

The tractor-loader was manufactured in 1958 by defendant and used and maintained by decedent’s employer since the date of purchase. A metallurgist called by plaintiff testified that the fracture of the steering knuckle was caused by fatigue rather than overload. A fatigue failure occurs progressively whereas an overload failure occurs instantaneously.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.