Supreme Court of South Carolina March 15, 1973, 19586 (South Carolina State Highway Department v. Booker)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-03-1973

Per Curiam:

We are of the opinion that the order of the Honorable William L. Rhodes, Jr., Trial Judge, properly sets forth and disposes all the issues submitted to this Court on appeal.

Let the order of Judge Rhodes be printed as the directive of this Court.

*250

ORDER OF JUDGE RHODES

On April 28, 1972, the South Carolina State Highway-Department served notice on the Condemnee of its taking of 16.89 acres of land owned by the Condemnee in Jasper County, South Carolina, for use as a Welcome Center. On May 16, 1972, the Board of Commissioners met and found the amount of just compensation, which was later tendered to the Condemnee by check. Within the Statutory time Condemnee appealed bringing the matter into this Court on a trial

de novo.

Both the Condemnor and the Condemnee served Interrogatories and started discovery proceedings under the rules provided therefor in this State.

On August 4, 1972, the Condemnee took the oral deposition of Mr. S. O. Holstein, Chief of the Right-of-Way Division of the South Carolina State Highway Department. During the deposition Mr. Holstein refused, on advice of counsel, to produce for inspection certain sketches, maps, pictures,

et cetera

enumerated in Condemnor’s Answers to Interrogatories on the ground that they were contained in appraisal reports which were privileged. A timely motion was served by Condemnee seeking an Order of this Court requiring the Condemnor to produce said items for inspection.

The Condemnee has served notice on Condemnor’s attorneys of his intention to take the oral deposition of Condemnor’s expert witnesses. Condemnor has notified Condemnee’s attorneys that its expert witnesses will be instructed not to answer questions concerning methods used or work done by the witnesses, or any other questions in regard to land evaluations found by the witnesses, on the grounds that the same are privileged and not discoverable.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.