West Virginia Supreme Court March 27, 1973, 13169 (Lusk v. Aetna Life Insurance Company)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-03-1973

Berry, President:

The Aetna Life Insurance Company, hereinafter referred to as defendant, appeals from a final order of the Circuit Court of Wyoming County entered August 30, 1971 wherein the Court, sitting in lieu of a jury, found in favor of Fred Lusk, hereinafter referred to as plaintiff, in the amount of $1200 based on a group disability insurance policy which covered Fred Lusk as an employee of Island Creek Coal Company. The defendant contends that the trial court erred in awarding the plaintiff $1200 in addition to the $1400 the defendant had already paid the plaintiff for his disability under the insurance policy. This Court granted defendant’s petition for an appeal on December 6, 1971 and the case was submitted for decision on February 6, 1973 on the briefs of the attorneys on behalf of the respective parties.

It appears from the record that Fred Lusk sustained serious facial injuries in a coal mine accident on October 18, 1967. Lusk sustained a broken nose, broken chin and a bilateral broken jaw, and underwent several operations as a result of these injuries. The group insurance policy stated that $50 per week would be paid to the insured up to a maximum of 52 weeks, but that no disability payments would be made for the first ninety days of any disability. The contract also stated that disability payments would be paid “ * * * for any period during

*551

which the Employee is wholly disabled by a disease or by an accidental bodily injury, and is prevented by such disability from performing any and every duty pertaining to the Employee’s occupation; * * * .” The policy also stated that no disability payments would be paid for any period during which the employee was not under the care of a qualified physician.

Under the terms of the insurance policy, the defendant began paying $50 per week to the plaintiff on January 17, 1968 and continued paying plaintiff through May 7, 1968.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.