Court of Appeals of Georgia November 29, 1973, 48421 (Buffington v. McClelland)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-11-1973
Hall, Presiding Judge.
Plaintiff-appellee McClelland is an attorney at law who previously represented appellant Buffington in litigation. Buffington refused to pay McClelland’s fee; McClelland sued to collect and obtained a jury verdict reversed on appeal in
Buffington v. McClelland,
125 Ga. App. 153 (186 SE2d 550). Upon a new trial, McClelland again received a jury verdict, and Buffington again appeals raising 12 enumerations of error.
Having been previously represented by McClelland in other matters, Buffington retained McClelland without a specific fee arrangement to defend him against a claim of one Ebener for a $60,000 recovery plus an accounting said to be due Ebener as his share of the profits of his former partnership with Buffington. The matter was initiated in 1956 and proceedings before an auditor and other matters caused the case to continue over 7
*461
years before it was concluded in 1963 by Buffington’s payment of a $7,000 settlement. During this time McClelland sent various bills "on account” and on conclusion sent a final bill which was not paid. The amended complaint sought recovery of an alleged balance due of $2,350. Upon the new trial McClelland amended his complaint to seek a balance due of $12,350, which reflected an increased valuation of services in quantum meruit at $15,000 minus adjustment for sums paid, and which McClelland explained as an amendment to conform the pleading to the evidence adduced at the first trial. The jury rendered a verdict for McClelland for $10,000, and Buffington appeals.
1. Enumerations one, two and four, asserting error in overruling the new trial motion, the motion for judgment n. o. v., and the motion for directed verdict on grounds that McClelland’s evidence was not sufficiently specific to support a recovery, all urge the general grounds. Buffington strongly urges that McClelland’s records, which never purported to be strictly accurate time records, are insufficient to enable him to recover.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit