District Court, W.D. Pennsylvania June 1, 1973, Civ. A. 71-1070 (Goodwin v. Hartford Life Insurance Company)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-06-1973

OPINION AND ORDER

McCUNE, District Judge.

Edith P. Goodwin brought this suit to recover the proceeds of a group life insurance policy which allegedly covered her deceased husband, Robert P. Goodwin. After a non jury trial we handed down an opinion and order on January 8, 1973, D.C., 352 F.Supp. 907, entering a judgment for the plaintiff for the face amount of the policy, $25,000.00, with interest.

Defendant, Hartford Life Insurance Company, has now filed a motion to amend or vacate judgment on three grounds. Except for the third ground, we do not think the motion raises new legal issues requiring extended discussion. It appears, instead, that it raises questions which in essence involve an interpretation of our previous opinion and order.

In our opinion we held, in short, that the doctrine of equitable estoppel applied so that Hartford could not avoid coverage after Goodwin’s death.

I

Defendant now argues that the doctrine of equitable estoppel is inapplicable here because in our discussion of the evidence adduced at trial, we did not make a finding of fact that Mr. Goodwin acted in good faith. Hartford asserts that “unless the court makes a finding of good faith on the part of the plaintiff’s decedent, and that he was in fact misled by the defendant’s conduct,

1

it must enter judgment for the defendant.” (Defendant’s brief, p. 6.).

We were not unaware of defendant’s position. As we observed in our opinion, “In order to apply estoppel in favor of an insured it is generally required that the insured shall have acted in good faith. . . .” (p. 16). We then held that on the basis of the facts we found no bad faith “sufficient to disqualify the plaintiff from claiming estoppel.” (p. 16). Our choice of words on this point may have been misleading. To accurately reflect our thinking we should have said that we found

no proof of bad faith sufficient to disqualify the plaintiff from claiming equitable estoppel.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.