Superior Court of Pennsylvania September 19, 1973, Appeal, 632 (Commonwealth v. Devlin)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-09-1973

combined-opinion

225 Pa. Superior Ct. 138 (1973) Commonwealth v. Devlin, Appellant. Superior Court of Pennsylvania. Submitted June 13, 1973. September 19, 1973. Before WRIGHT, P.J., WATKINS, JACOBS, HOFFMAN, SPAULDING, CERCONE, and SPAETH, JJ. Merle K. Evey, and Patterson, Evey, Routch & Black, for appellant. Amos Davis, District Attorney, for Commonwealth, appellee. OPINION PER CURIAM, September 19, 1973: Judgment of sentence affirmed. DISSENTING OPINION BY HOFFMAN, J.: This is an appeal from a judgment of sentence imposed upon appellant after he was found guilty by a jury of sodomy. As the basis for his appeal, appellant *139 contends that the Commonwealth did not prove with sufficient specificity the date the crime was committed. The complainant was twenty-two years old, but had the intellectual development of a six or seven year old child. Because he was unable to manage his business affairs, a social worker made arrangements with the appellant for him to receive the complainant's wages and make disbursements as needed. This arrangement continued from February of 1971 to April 14, 1972. Although the indictment indicated April 16, 1972 as the date of the incident, the trial court found as a fact that the offense occurred sometime between February of 1971 and April 14, 1972.[1] The court below held that the Commonwealth is not bound to prove that the crime occurred on the date specified in the indictment, provided that some date is shown with reasonable certainty, and within the statute of limitations. With this general proposition, I agree. I do not believe, however, that a date was shown with any reasonable certainty in the instant case where the evidence only showed that the alleged offense occurred sometime within a fourteen month period. In my opinion the instant case is clearly controlled by this court's decision in Commonwealth v. Levy, 146 Pa. Superior Ct. 564, 23 A. 2d 97 (1941).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.