Supreme Court of Missouri September 10, 1973, 57492, 58076 (State v. Horn)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-09-1973

HOLMAN, Judge.

In 1951 Nathaniel Horn (hereinafter referred to as defendant) was found guilty of statutory rape and his punishment fixed by the jury at life imprisonment. In 1970 defendant filed a motion to vacate the judgment under Rule 27.26, V.A.M.R. After an evidentiary hearing the trial court made findings adverse to defendant on contentions relating to the trial. The court, however, did find that defendant had not been properly advised of his right to appeal and therefore set aside the judgment and resentenced defendant so as to give him an opportunity to appeal from his original conviction. Defendant appealed from the ruling on the 27.26 motion, and from his conviction. The two appeals have been consolidated here. We will first consider the appeal from the 1951 conviction. .

The defendant does not challenge the sufficiency of the evidence and hence a brief statement of facts will suffice. The prosecutrix, whom we will refer to as Mary Ann, was the nine-year-old daughter of two deaf mutes. In February 1950, she was admitted to the Niles Home for Negro Children located in Kansas City. On Sunday, March 5, 1950, in the late afternoon or early evening, Mary Ann ran away from the Home and went to a movie. Later that night she left the movie and rode a streetcar to 12th Street and Troost where she alighted with the intention of walking to the home of her parents. When she reached the intersection of 12th Street and Charlotte she was grabbed from behind by a man later identified as the defendant. The man dragged her to a “dark place” on a vacant lot adjoining the Lucille Hotel. He hit her head against a rock, threatened to kill her with a knife if she did not stop screaming, and then raped her. After a time he tried to drag her into a building (apparently the Lucille Hotel) but she pulled away and fled. Upon arriving at her parents’ home she reported what had happened and the police and an ambulance were summoned.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.