Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas March 28, 1973, 46016 (Gillon v. State of Texas)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-03-1973

OPINION

DALLY, Commissioner.

The conviction is for robbery by assault; the punishment forty years imprisonment.

The appellant’s first complaint is that he was denied the right to cross-examine a witness.

The witness Jackson was the only witness who was able to identify the appellant as being a participant in the robbery. Prior to trial, by a motion in limine, and again after Jackson had testified on direct examination and was passed for cross-examination, the appellant’s counsel urged the court to rule that the State would not be permitted to introduce evidence which would show that he had committed other robberies near the time of the commission of the robbery for which he was on trial. The court refused to rule at either time that the State would be absolutely prohibited from introducing this evidence but made it plain that he would not permit the introduction of such testimony until it was shown to be an exception to the general rule that such evidence is not admissible. The appellant did not cross-examine Jackson and the State did not attempt to introduce evidence which would tend to show or would show the commission of other robberies.

The appellant contends that the court placed his counsel in an “intolerable dilemma” and that he was deprived of the right of cross-examination, a right implicit in the constitutional guarantee of the right of confrontation and to effective assistance of counsel.

Trial counsel are often called upon to make difficult decisions. This is a part of

*894

their task. The appellant’s counsel in his briefs states that “cross-examination in this case could have been effective but the threat of extraneous offenses in evidence far outweighed the benefit of cross-examination.”

Counsel contends that a part of the “intolerable dilemma” was caused by his belief that the law permitted the State to introduce extraneous offenses if he effectively cross-examined the witness Jackson. This court has recently expressed itself on this facet of the law.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.