Supreme Court of Minnesota February 2, 1973, 42670, 43464, 43465 (Real Estate Tax Assessments of Real Property of Silver Lake Apartments, Inc. v. County of Olmsted)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-02-1973

Per Curiam.

These are appeals from orders denying alternative motions for amended findings of fact, conclusions of law, and order for judgment, or a new trial.

Taxpayer, Silver Lake Apartments, Inc., owns a complex of apartment buildings in Rochester, Olmsted County, Minnesota. The complex, built in 1950, has 8 buildings with a total of 126 apartments. Olmsted County determined that the full and true value of the complex for tax purposes was $332,940. Taxpayer commenced separate actions contesting the real estate taxes payable in 1967,1968, and 1969, alleging that the evaluation was excessive. The actions were consolidated for trial and appeal.

The trial court found the full and true value of the complex to be $281,000, and the fair market value to be $843,000, for each of the years in question. Taxpayer argues that the fair market value does not exceed $750,000 and vigorously contends that the evidence does not support the trial court’s evaluation.

Both parties employed competent, independent appraisers to establish the fair market value of the property. Taxpayer’s appraiser testified that by use of the various accepted and customary appraisal approaches to determine valuation, he arrived at values ranging from ap

*549

proximately $713,600 to $750,000. After considering and weighing all approaches, he valued the property at $727,500. The county’s appraiser, again using the customary appraisal approaches, arrived at values ranging from $856,000 to $875,000 and testified that the fair market value was $875,000. The only other appraisal witness was the county assessor. Using only one approach in his appraisal, the depreciated replacement cost, he determined the value to be slightly in excess of $1 million. On cross-examination it was effectively established that the assessor’s use of only this one approach was an inadequate basis to establish the value of the subject premises.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.