United States Customs Court June 11, 1973, C.D. 4431; Protest 67/89525-4165, 68/27935-4284 (FW Myers & Co., Inc. v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-06-1973

FORD, Judge:

The above cases, consolidated for the purpose of trial, involve the proper classification of certain household effects of returning residents. The merchandise is claimed to be free of duty under items 810.10 and 813.10, Tariff Schedules of the United States. At the time of entry an affidavit, customs form 3297 (later modified and numbered 3299), was not submitted to customs pursuant to Part 10 of the Customs Regulations. Said affidavits were filed after the expiration of the bond period, prior to liquidation in protest 68/27935 and subsequent to liquidation and the timely filing of a protest in 67/89525.

Plaintiff contends it has complied with the regulations and is free from willful negligence. Defendant on the other hand claims the regulations were not complied with since Customs Regulation, section 10.112 permits the late filing of such a document only in the absence of willful negligence. It is the position of defendant that not only has plaintiff failed to establish freedom from willful negligence but defendant has affirmatively established such conduct.

The pertinent portions of the statutes and regulations involved provide as follows :

Furniture, and parts thereof, not specially provided for:

*

*

* * * -x- * *

727.55 Other.................................. 20% ad val.

•x- * * * * * -x-

Articles imported by or for the account of any person arriving in the United States from a foreign country:

810.10 Books, libraries, usual and reasonable furniture, and similar household effects, if actually used abroad by him or by him and his family not less than one year, and not intended for any other person, or for

sale ................................. Free

* * -X- -X- -X- -X- * *

Articles imported by or for the account of any person arriving in the United States who is a returning resident thereof: * * *

*431

813.10 All personal and household effects taken

abroad by him or for his account........ Free

Tariff Act of 1930, as amended:

Sec. 498.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.