Wisconsin Supreme Court January 30, 1973, 145 (Bigley v. Brandau)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-01-1973

Beilfuss, J.

The appellants assert that the judgment should be reversed in the interest of justice. This court does have the discretionary power to reverse a trial court judgment, direct entry of a proper judgment or remand for a new trial by virtue of sec. 251.09, Stats.

1

The appellants’ brief does not specify whether they seek a new trial or reversal and judgment.

The rule that has been consistently followed is that this court will not exercise its discretionary power to order a new trial unless it is convinced there has been a probable miscarriage of justice and that a new trial would probably produce a different result.

2

*201

The defendants-appellants challenge the sufficiency of the evidence to support the jury findings that a valid contract existed and that the defendant-appellant Bran-dau was the agent of the other defendants-appellants.

There is a voluminous record in the matter and we will not attempt to restate all the evidence for the principal reason the test is that if there is any credible evidence to sustain the verdict it must be upheld.

While some of the facts are in dispute, the material and reliable evidence sufficient to sustain the verdict is as follows:

The plaintiff-respondent James P. Bigley was a stockholder in the Tri-County Finance Company. The appellant Harvey M. Brandau (hereinafter Brandau) became a branch manager of Tri-County Finance (hereinafter company) in February of 1966. On November 12, 1969, Brandau became the company’s acting president. He was also a stockholder, director and chairman of the board. The other defendants-appellants (hereinafter defendants) were also directors, officers and branch managers of the company.

On November 17, 1969, the defendants held a company board meeting which one Attorney Endicott attended.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.