Appellate Court of Illinois September 17, 1973, 72-107 (Sheldon Livestock Co. v. Western Engine Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-09-1973
Mr. JUSTICE SEIDENFELD
delivered the opinion of the court:
The plaintiff, Sheldon Livestock Company, Inc., filed a three count complaint against Western Engine Company as agent, and Detroit Diesel Company as principal, seeking damages for repairs and loss of time and use of its truck-tractor as the result of an overhaul of the truck by Western Engine Company. Count I alleged negligent repair; Count II alleged breach of contract to perform in a workmanlike manner; and Count III alleged breach of express warranty. Detroit Diesel’s motion for summary judgment was granted on the basis that Western Engine. Company was not its agent. The case proceeded to trial, was submitted to the jury on only the first two counts, and resulted in a verdict for plaintiff in the amount of $5,350. Defendant appeals from the judgment entered on the verdict.
Defendant contends: (1) That the court erred in instructing the jury on both contract and negligent theories, claiming that this prejudicially allowed two avenues of recovery for breach of the same alleged duty of ordinary care; (2) that the testimony of plaintiff’s expert witness on causation lacked proper foundation, and further, applied standards of care which were neither universal nor applicable for defendant’s locality; (3) that plaintiff failed to prove freedom from contributory negligence by failure to produce evidence of proper use, maintenance or repair for the 90,000 miles the engine ran after defendant’s overhaul; and (4) that undocumented evidence of loss' of profits was improperly admitted.
The evidence shows that in December, 1969, defendant performed an overhaul on the Detroit Diesel engine of plaintiff’s truck at a cost of $3,479.29. It is. agreed by both parties that no main bearing stabilizers were installed during this repair. Approximately 10 months and-90,000 miles later, the truck broke down..
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit