Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court January 5, 1973 (Robert Industries, Inc. v. Spence)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-01-1973

Braucher, J.

The plaintiff filed two bills in the Superior Court. The first sought an accounting for the interference by the defendant Spence, through the defendant corporations controlled by him, with a right granted to the plaintiff by the Metropolitan District Commission (MDC). The second sought a declaration that a lease from the MDC to the plaintiff gave the plaintiff an exclusive right to serve food for money on George’s Island in Boston Harbor and also sought an

*752

injunction against such activity on the part of Spence and his corporations. One of the defendant corporations in the first suit,- Massachusetts Bay Lines, Inc., by counterclaim sought damages for unfair competition.

The judge made findings, rulings and an order for decree in each case, ruled that the plaintiff has the exclusive right it claims, and granted the declaratory relief and injunction prayed for in the second suit. In the first suit he found that the defendants acted in the honest belief, in accordance with an opinion of MDC counsel, that the lease did not grant the exclusive right claimed, and dismissed the bill. In view of his findings in the companion case he found no damage on the counterclaim. The defendants appeal from the final decrees in both suits. The evidence is reported.

We summarize the judge’s findings. Before 1967 Spence or his corporation had a lease from the MDC as a concessionaire on George’s Island, and ran clambakes. During 1967 and 1968 there was no concessionaire on the island, and the facilities fell into disrepair. During this period Spence or his corporations continued to run clambakes on the island, using some of the same facilities. On May 14, 1969, the MDC leased to the ■ plaintiff for five years portions of three buildings and certain adjoining areas on the island for the purpose of running a food and beverage concession. The lease refers to use of one of the buildings as an "indoor picnic area,” and the plaintiff serves clambakes there in inclement weather.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.