Supreme Court of Iowa March 28, 1973, 55272 (Oehlert Ex Rel. Oehlert v. Kramer)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-03-1973
HARRIS, Justice.
We reverse the trial court’s judgment for two plaintiffs in an automobile accident case. Two nonjury personal injury cases were consolidated for trial. Both plaintiffs were guests who charged defendant with recklessness in the operation of a motor vehicle at night through a series of four curves. For simplicity we ignore the fact that each suit was brought by the father of the minor guests claiming injury and that the new automobile was owned by defendant driver’s father.
Gerrald Kramer (defendant) met plaintiffs (Bob and David) at a drive-in in Clear Lake on the night of April 11, 1967. The three youths were well acquainted. Bob and defendant spent considerable time discussing the new cars both were driving. It was decided to take a drive in defendant’s vehicle and the three left the drive-in proceeding west on Iowa Highway 18. Defendant drove. Bob rode on the passen
*725
ger’s side of the front seat while David sat in the middle of the back seat.
They soon left Highway 18 and entered a blacktop county road, known officially as Cerro Gordo County Road B and unofficially as the Fertile road. The car left the Fertile road out of control about three fourths of a mile north of where the youths had entered it. The road, which was well known to defendant, has four rather pronounced curves within the three quarters of a mile and is not constructed for high speed travel. The posted speed limit for night was SO miles per hour.
The new car was “run through the gears,” and accelerated to a high speed. The car negotiated the first three curves but failed on the fourth. There was direct evidence the car was traveling 90 miles per hour as it entered the curve it failed to negotiate. All the youths suffered personal injuries. In these suits for the injuries to Bob and David the trial court, sitting as the trier of facts, found recklessness on the part of defendant and fixed the amount of recoveries. On appeal, defendant assigns three errors.
I.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit