Supreme Court of Iowa March 28, 1973, 55531 (In Re the Estate of Brown)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-03-1973
LeGRAND, Justice.
This appeal asks us to answer the question whether several insurance policies on the life of Milford E. Brown are subject to Iowa Inheritance tax. The Iowa Department of Revenue (hereafter called department) appeals from the trial court’s ruling that they are not. We affirm that order.
Milford E. Brown and his wife, Ruth, were killed in an automobile accident in 1968. Milford E. Brown (hereafter called decedent) survived his wife by several hours. Decedent was insured by five policies with death benefits totalling $30,500.-00. Ruth Brown was insured by policies having death benefits of $18,000.00. Originally this controversy involved the proceeds of her policies, too, but the department has appealed only from that portion of the trial court’s order which holds the insurance proceeds from decedent’s policies exempt from inheritance tax.
Decedent’s will makes no mention of insurance. The policies themselves designate no beneficiary. The parties agree the insurance funds are payable to decedent’s two adult children under section 511.37, The Code, 1968, but disagree as to whether they must pay inheritance tax on the money they receive.
*926
The case turns on the interpretation we give two relevant statutes, the pertinent parts of which we set out as follows:
“Section 511.37. A policy of insurance on the life of an individual, in the absence of an agreement or assignment to the contrary, shall inure to the separate use of the husband or wife and children of said individual, independently of his creditors. * * * ”
“Section 450.3(1). The [inheritance] tax hereby imposed shall be collected upon the net market value and shall go into the general fund of the state tó be determined as herein provided, of any property passing: (1) By will or under the statutes of inheritance of this or any other state or country. * * * ”
The case was submitted on stipulated facts and the parties concede there is but one issue: Is section 511.37 a statute of inheritance?
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit