Court of Appeals of Texas December 12, 1973, 896 (Beken v. Elstner)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-12-1973

CURTISS BROWN, Justice.

This is a suit for damages for the conversion of certain crops.

Appellant Arthur Ray Beken purchased a farm from appellees Polk, Greenberg, and Hebert on July 7, 1971. Prior to that sale, appellee Alfred John Elstner had leased the farm for the purpose of growing certain crops. He had farmed under consecutive one-year oral leases from 1965 to

*410

1970, each lease running from July 1 to June 30. In September 1970, the lessor died and the land passed to appellees Polk, Greenberg, and Hebert. Elstner testified that he agreed with the new owners to take a one-year lease from January 1, 1971, to December 31, 1971. He also testified inconsistently that his lease ended on June 30, 1971. In July 1971, Elstner had growing crops on the land. After the sale, Arthur Ray Beken refused to allow Elstner to harvest most of the crop. Elstner brought suit for conversion; Beken brought a cross-action against Elstner for the value of the crop harvested and a third party action against his vendors alleging a breach of their covenant of general warranty. Trial was to a jury which found, in response to special issues, that Elstner had a lease agreement with Polk, Greenberg, and Hebert which entitled him to remove his crops subsequent to the conveyance to Be-ken. It also found that Arthur Beken (father of the appellant and his agent in negotiating the sale) represented to Polk that Elstner would be allowed to remove his crop and that Polk relied on that representation. Judgment was entered for $5,000 for Elstner against appellant, and take-nothing judgments were entered in the other actions.

Appellant brings eight points of error. Points three through five complain that the trial court erred in allowing various testimony of statements by Arthur Be-ken to the effect that Elstner would be allowed to harvest his crop. Appellant filed a motion in limine with regard to such testimony, and it was overruled.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.