Missouri Court of Appeals July 23, 1973, KCD26214 (Doyle v. Doyle)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-07-1973
PER CURIAM.
This case arose when William E. Doyle, Wilda Doyle’s former husband, moved to modify their divorce decree to terminate alimony payments. He alleged that Wilda (1) entered into a common law marriage in Kansas and (2) was now an able-bodied woman who could support herself. The trial court denied his motion and he appealed. Appellant has abandoned his second contention on appeal and relies solely on his allegation that Wilda Doyle had entered into a common law marriage in Kansas. He claims the court’s judgment was not supported by sufficient evidence. His claim must be denied, and the judgment affirmed.
*847
As the case below was tried to a judge, Rule 73.01, V.A.M.R., will control the review on appeal. The evidence will be considered de novo, giving due deference to the trial judge’s findings in view of his opportunity to observe the demeanor of the witnesses. Only if the judgment below was “clearly erroneous” may it be reversed.
In reviewing the evidence all uncontested facts will be considered as true and inferences most favorable to the prevailing party will be drawn. Dill v. Poindexter, 451 S.W.2d 365 (Mo.App.1970). The evidence was that in February of 1972 Wilda and Richard C. Doyle (of no relation to the parties here) purchased a house in Leavenworth, Kansas in their joint names. Both the loan taken out to purchase the house and the deed to the property were made out to Richard and Wilda Doyle as husband and wife. The parties testified that this was an erroneous designation of their status resulting from a misunderstanding caused by the savings and loan company’s and realtor’s assumption that they were married. The fact that they had the same last name was, in their view, the cause of the mistake. Both Wilda and Richard Doyle testified that they did not tell the bank or realtor to correct this designation after they discovered it because they felt it had no real meaning.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit