New York Court of Appeals February 8, 1973 (People v. Sanders)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-02-1973
combined-opinion
31 N.Y.2d 463 (1973) The People of the State of New York, Respondent, v. Willie Sanders, Appellant. Court of Appeals of the State of New York. Argued January 8, 1973. Decided February 8, 1973. Bruce K. Carpenter for appellant. Michael F. Dillon, District Attorney (Richard M. Mancuso of counsel), for respondent. Judges BURKE, JONES and WACHTLER concur with Chief Judge FULD; Judge JASEN concurs in a separate opinion; Judges BREITEL and GABRIELLI taking no part. *465Chief Judge FULD. Some five months after the defendant's indictment for burglary in April of 1967, his assigned counsel moved to suppress evidence taken from his apartment on the ground that it had been illegally obtained. Following a hearing, the court denied the motion and, in our view, properly so. That pretrial hearing was held and decided on Thursday, September 28, 1967, the day before the trial was scheduled to begin. On the next day, the jury was selected and the trial adjourned, over the weekend, to Monday, October 2. On that day, prior to any further trial proceedings and before counsel opened to the jury, the defendant's attorney requested a copy of the minutes of the pretrial hearing, as well as an adjournment to allow for their transcription. He explained that his delay in making the *466 request was owing to his inability earlier to communicate with the administrator of the local assigned counsel program in connection with the matter. The court denied the request, and the trial proceeded, culminating two days later in the jury's verdict of guilt. We have consistently held that an indigent defendant has a "fundamental constitutional right" to a free transcript of the minutes of a pretrial suppression hearing and that its denial requires a reversal of the judgment of conviction, even though no prejudice be shown and "[r]egardless of the nature and quantum of proof against" him. (People v. West, 29 N Y 2d 728, 729; see, also, People v. Peacock, 31 N Y 2d 907; People v.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit