Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit March 9, 1973, 72-2568 (Faye Bolton v. The Travelers Insurance Company)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-03-1973

JOHN R. BROWN, Chief Judge:

This is a Texas diversity case. Desirous of deciding it with dispatch but worshipping accuracy more dearly than speed we awaited the decision of the Supreme Court of Texas in Latham v. Security Insurance Company of Hartford, Tex., 1972, 491 S.W.2d 100. The questions which this appeal presents which are deserving of serious consideration were dealt with frontally by the Texas high Court which laid down rules for their resolution. Nonetheless, we must still beat a hasty retreat from ignorance to speculation and determine whether we think the Texas Supreme Court would hold, under its second rule announced in

Latham,

that a party who voluntarily places himself within the Court’s jurisdiction shall be considered to have been “joined”. Believing that the Texas Court would so hold, we reverse the District Court’s dismissal for want of jurisdiction and remand for trial on the merits.

1

Appellee Bolton was injured within the course and scope of her employment by Walter Kidde & Co. Inc., Webber Aircraft. She filed her claim against Employer and Travelers with the Industrial Accident Board (IAB) of the state of Texas on June 28, 1971. Travelers notified the IAB that the “Charter Oak Fire Insurance Company” was the correct carrier. Travelers and Charter Oak, corporate

'pe.re et fil,

shared common claims offices, officers, management and staffs.

2

The IAB found that

*178

indeed, Charter Oak was the correct carrier and its award ordered the payment of over $17,000 in a lump sum as compensation for total permanent disability. Appellee Bolton, through her counsel, gave written notice of appeal to the IAB and the parties naming Employer and Charter Oak in the caption which was incorporated by reference in the body of the notice as “the final ruling — and award of * * * [IAB] * * * in the above styled and numbered cause — .” Counsel then filed suit to set aside the Board’s award naming only Travelers as a defendant with no mention of Charter Oak.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.