Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit March 26, 1973, 71-1033, 71-1509 (United States v. Walter E. Ashe, United States of America v. Walter E. Ashe)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-03-1973
LEVENTHAL, Circuit Judge:
This is the third time that we have been asked to review some phase of the Government’s case against Walter Ashe. In this latest chapter of the proceedings, Ashe was found not guilty by reason of insanity of a violation of 22 D.C. Code § 2801, carnal knowledge of a female child under sixteen years of age. In 71-1033, Ashe appeals the finding of guilt of the commission of the act, which is implicit in an acquittal by reason of insanity. In 71-1509, he appeals from the determination, following a Bolton
1
hearing for his continued custody on the basis of dangerousness because of mental illness.
*664
I.
The indictment charges that on October 14, 1967, Walter Ashe had sexual relations with his daughter Mary, then age ten. The Government’s evidence consisted of the testimony of Mary Ashe; the corroborative evidence of Mary’s then eight or nine year old brother Walter, Jr. and of their mother Mrs. Ashe, both of whom were witnesses to the incident; the testimony of Thomas Ashe, a still-younger brother, who was not a witness to the event itself; and the expert testimony of a pediatrician who examined Mary after the incident. On May 9, 1968, Ashe was brought to trial. Mrs. Ashe invoked her marital privilege. Mary and Walter, Jr. were questioned in order to judge their competency to give evidence. Walter, Jr.’s responses were unclear, and he eventually became unresponsive. At length, defense moved for a mistrial in order that a more thorough examination of Ashe’s capacity to stand trial be undertaken. This motion was granted by District Judge Smith.
Ashe was determined fit to stand trial and on October 2, 1968, a second trial was begun before District Judge Green. At this trial, the Government rested its case substantially upon the evidence of Mary and Walter, Jr. Mary’s testimony was elicited only with the greatest of difficulty. The first time she took the stand, she did not give damaging testimony.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit