Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit April 20, 1973, 26736 (Marcia W. Seaman v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-04-1973

WALLACE, Circuit Judge:

In the beginning of 1967, taxpayer, Marcia Seaman, was legally married. On March 22, 1967, she received an interlocutory decree of divorce according to then California law. The decree contained the following notice:

This is not a judgment of divorce. The parties are still husband and wife, and will be such until a Final Judgment of Divorce is entered after one year from the date of service of copy of summons and complaint upon the defendant spouse.

She obtained a final judgment of divorce in 1968.

Taxpayer worked as a stenographer during 1967, the tax year in question. To facilitate her employment, she spent at least $900 for the daytime care of her two children. She filed an individual return for 1967 and took a $900 childcare deduction. The commissioner disallowed the deduction and the taxpayer filed a petition with the Tax Court for redetermination of the deficiency. After the court sustained the commissioner’s determination, she appealed. We affirm.

In 1967, the applicable code section was 26 U.S.C. (Int.Rev.Code of 1954) § 214.

1

That section generally allowed a deduction for the expenses of child care necessary to allow the earning of income. In the case of a working wife, the deduction was available only if the spouses filed a joint return. Marcia Seaman and her husband did not file a joint return.

Thus she was not eligible for the deduction unless she could avail herself of one of the two exceptions contained in § 214(d)(5). One of these applied only if the woman had been deserted by her husband and she had not known his whereabouts at any time during the tax year. Marcia Seaman stipulated that she had known her husband’s whereabouts and thus this exception was unavailable to her.

The other exception would have applied if Mrs. Seaman had been “legally separated from her spouse under a decree of divorce or of separate mainte

*338

nance at the close of the taxable year . . . § 214(d)(5)(A).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.