Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit August 6, 1973, 72-1504 (United States v. Thomas M. Phillips, A/K/A Thomas P. Bailey)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-08-1973
BAZELON, Chief Judge:
Appellant was convicted of robbery.
1
Since the grounds urged for reversal are without merit, the conviction is affirmed. But there is a matter relating to the administration of the Youth Corrections Act which requires our attention.
Appellant was 20 years of age at the time of his conviction and, at the direction of the trial judge, was evaluated for Youth Corrections commitment pursuant to section 5010(e) of the Act. The 5010(e) report recommended adult sentencing and, relying on that report, the trial judge imposed an adult sentence of 2-6 years. The sentencing occurred before this court's decisions in United States v. Coefield and United States v. Reed & Hoston.
2
This case was on appeal when those decisions issued. We think they require that, in the present case, the sentence be vacated and the case remanded for reconsideration of Youth Corrections treatment.
I
An offender less than 22 years of age at the time of his conviction is eligible for Youth Corrections Act treatment.
3
The Act provides the trial judge with four options: (1) granting probation, § 5010(a); (2) committing the offender to a federal Youth Center for up to six years’ indeterminate sentence, § 5010(b); (3) committing the offender
*1202
for a maximum term of over six years but not exceeding the maximum sentence for the crime involved, § 5010(c); or (4) sentencing the offender as an adult, § 5010(d). “Congress [has] found that young people between the ages of 16-22, especially, were hopeful subjects for rehabilitation,” hence clothed them with a presumptive right to treatment under the Act.
4
Accordingly, an adult sentence may be imposed
“only if
the applicable facts in the individual case meet the statutory requirements,”
5
which include a finding that the offender “will
not
[derive] benefit from rehabilitative treatment” under the Act.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit