Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit June 29, 1973, 71-1377 (United States v. Melvin L. Grady)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-06-1973
LEVENTHAL, Circuit Judge.
On this appeal from a conviction for second degree murder, we hold that the court erred in its failure to give an appropriate instruction on manslaughter advising the jury that in the event of a homicide resulting from a gross deviation from reasonable care the verdict should be manslaughter if the jury did not find malice beyond a reasonable doubt. The case is remanded for a' new trial unless the Government consents to, and the trial court determines it is in the interest of justice to enter, a judgment and sentence for manslaughter.
1
A.
Facts
The pitiful victim of the homicide was Gretehen Grady, appellant’s three year old daughter. Her mother’s sister Valerie heard two thumps in the Grady bedroom, heard Gretehen yelling and crying, and assumed appellant was beating Gretehen, an occurrence she testified was common. Valerie did not investigate, her previous efforts to stop appellant’s beatings having proved futile.
However, her sister Eileen went to the Grady bedroom and found appellant holding Gretehen slightly off the ground and shaking her. He explained the child had been eating “rat poison.” She examined Gretchen’s mouth, found only baby powder, and asked why appellant was beating the child. Appellant told her to mind her own business.
Eileen left to feed her own baby, but returned shortly after on hearing a “thump.” This time she found Gretehen being held at the shoulders by appellant, crying and telling her Daddy: “Don’t hit me any more. Daddy, don’t be angry any more — I won’t do it no more.” Eileen asked appellant to stop, but she was again told to mind her own business and she returned to her room.
Within a couple of minutes, Eileen heard “two more thumps,” rushed into the room again and found Gretehen motionless on the floor, her eyes rolled back in her head, and blood trickling from her mouth. Eileen found appellant in another bedroom, and asked what was wrong. Appellant said Gretehen was lying on the floor, being stubborn.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit