Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit July 26, 1973, 73-1135 (Clifton D. Mayhew, Inc. v. Blake Construction Company, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-07-1973

WIDENER, Circuit Judge:

This is a diversity case tried under Virginia law brought by Mayhew, Incorporated against Blake Construction Company. Blake was the prime contractor for the construction of United States Federal Office Building No. 7 in the District of Columbia. Blake subcontracted with Mayhew for the latter to perform the painting, finishing, and wall covering work on Building No. 7.

Article 3 of the subcontract provided that Mayhew would receive $140,000 for its work, subject, however, to additions and deductions for changes in the work according to the other provisions of the contract. Article 4(a)(1) provided that partial payments to the subcontractor shall be made within 5 days after the contractor received payment from the owners. Article 4(f) provided that Mayhew would not be entitled to final payment until forty-five days after the completion and acceptance of the entire project. Article 23 provided that Blake, without invalidating the contract, could require changes, additions, and/or omissions in the work, upon written orders to Mayhew. Mayhew was to present an itemized estimate of the value of the work involved and to perform the work if so ordered by Blake. Then, upon determination, by Blake, of the value of the work involved, Blake was to issue a change order to Mayhew, adjusting the contract amount accordingly. Furthermore, Mayhew was obligated to perform all work pertaining tó the project as Blake should direct. Article 28 provided that if any legal action arose between Blake and the United States and which concerned work performed by Mayhew, then Blake could select counsel of its own choosing to represent both parties’ interests in any such action.

*1262

During the performance of the subcontract, a dispute arose as to whether or not the painting of certain concrete floors was covered by the contract or whether it was extra work. The work was completed around July, 1967.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.