Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit October 31, 1973, 1123, Docket 73-2023 (United States v. Vincent Rollins)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-10-1973

OAKES, Circuit Judge:

This is the second time this case has been before the court in respect to this court’s now superseded Rules Regarding Prompt Disposition of Criminal Cases, often referred to as the Second Circuit Speedy Trial Rules.

1

The appellee was arrested on March 30, 1972, charged with having sold heroin to an undercover agent. He was indicted on April 28, 1972, and pleaded not

*411

guilty on May 15, 1972. On October 13, 1972, he moved to dismiss the indictment, on the basis that the Government had failed to indicate its readiness to bring him to trial within the six months required by then Rule 4. The Government admitted that “the six-month date, quite frankly, slipped past . . .,” but alleged “exceptional circumstances” on the basis that the undercover agent who had allegedly bought the heroin from Rollins was himself under investigation, being suspected in an unrelated case of having permitted an informant to take some heroin the agent had purchased. The Government was unwilling to risk the “serious danger that cross-examination of the police officer . . . would have compromised the investigation” into the agent’s behavior, and, desiring also to protect his reputation, decided to wait until that investigation was disposed of.

Under Rule 4 the Government was required' to be ready for trial within six months

2

except for certain periods excluded from the time computed. The district court originally found that this situation satisfied the requirements of Rule 5(h)

3

allowing for an exclusion of time for “exceptional circumstances,” but held that the Government was required to move for an extension to be able to qualify for such an exclusion. Because the Government had not so moved, the district court dismissed the indictment. In United States v. Rollins, 475 F.2d 1108 (2d Cir. 1973)

(Rollins

I), we held that the Government was not required to move for an extension to qualify for the Rule 5(h) exclusion.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.