Ohio Court of Appeals March 13, 1973, 72-CA-8 (Highlandview Nursing Homes, Inc. v. Totalcare, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-03-1973

*152

Keeks, J.

This is an appeal from a judgment of the Court of Common Pleas of Miami County granting an injunction to the plaintiff, Highland View Nursing Homes, Inc., appellee herein, which prohibits the defendant, Total-care, Inc., appellant herein, from constructing and operating a nursing home on premises located in Troy, Ohio.

On March 1, 1963, Daniel Taubman and Naomi M. Taubman owned a tract of land known as Highland Park, which contained approximately twenty-nine acres. At that time, the Taubmans entered into a lease with Highland View Nursing Homes, Inc., for a term of fifteen years covering part of the twenty-nine acre parcel. This lease was duly recorded and contained the following provision:

“9.

Limitation of Competition.

Lessors shall not operate or permit to be operated on any of the remaining area now owned by them and formerly known as Highland Park either a nursing home, rest home, mild mental patient facility or alcoholic home such as are licensed by the Department of Health of the State of Ohio, said land being further described as follows: [then follows a metes and bounds description of the 29.559 acres of the land owned by lessors].”

On June 30,1967, Daniel and Naomi Taubman conveyed 8.275 acres of the land involved in the lease to Eobert Gradsky. On March 2, 1970, the defendant herein, Total-care, Inc., made an offer to purchase the Gradsky property, which was contingent, among other things, upon the obtaining of zoning clearance to build and operate a nursing home upon the premises. This offer was accepted by Allan Gradsky, as executor of the estate of Eobert Gradsky, on March 25, 1970.

On July 30, 1970, an application for a zoning certificate to build a nursing home on the Gradsky land was made by Totalcare, Inc., with the board of zoning appeals for Miami County.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.