Court of Appeals of Texas February 9, 1973, No. 17386 (Walker v. Vaughn)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-02-1973
OPINION
MASSEY, Chief Justice.
As ultimately resolved, suit was by Don T. Walker and others as plaintiffs against Mack D. Vaughan, Jr. and his wife, hereinafter treated as defendant in the singular. Plaintiffs sought mandatory injunction which would, as to the residence defendant had erected upon his subdivision lot, compel him to either comply with applicable building restrictions or to remove therefrom the improvements, including his residence.
Following trial on the merits the court, sitting without a jury, rendered judgment denying the relief for which plaintiffs sued.
Reversed, Injunction ordered.
The subdivision in question was the Montecito Addition to the City of Denton. By its plat and dedication, under which all interested parties had purchased, restrictive covenants were specified, including that by Paragraph 10, reading in part as follows: “10. At least sixty (60) per cent of the exposed exterior wall area of all residences must be of brick, stone, or stucco *490The defendant had erected and completed the construction of his residence without compliance with the restriction, in that by his own witness’ evidence as to maximum percentage only approximately thirty-five (35%) per cent of the exposed exterior wall area of his residence being of brick, stone, or stucco.
Included in the covenants was a provision relative to approval of the plans of any building to be erected therein by an architectural control committee, composed of the President, Vice-President, and Secretary-Treasurer of the Montecito Corporation, promoter of the subdivision. We are not troubled with a construction of such provision since the evidence is undisputed that there was never an act of approval or disapproval of the defendant’s plans for construction by the committee, as such, though one member of the committee orally advised the defendant of his approval of the building plan prior to construction.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit