Missouri Court of Appeals June 26, 1973, No. 34960 (Hayes v. Jayne)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-06-1973

SMITH, Presiding Judge.

Appellants, the executor and certain beneficiaries under the will of Myrtle Hayes, *831appeal from the action of the trial court in quieting title to certain farm land in Este-lene Hayes.

On May 27, 1940, Myrtle Hayes conveyed a piece of property, by warranty deed, to Hughie C. Hayes, her son, and Es-telene Hayes, his wife. Myrtle reserved to herself a life estate in the land. The deed was acknowledged but never recorded. The consideration was one dollar and “love and affection.” On the same day Myrtle, Hughie and Estelene entered into a “contract and lease” of the same land, in which Myrtle leased the land to Hughie and Este-lene for $150 per year commencing March 1, 1941, and terminating on the death of Myrtle. The lessees agreed to pay all taxes and insurance; to keep all buildings and improvements in good repair; and to farm the lands in good and husbandlike manner. Hughie and Estelene (until Hughie’s death in 1959), and Estelene thereafter, performed all the conditions of the lease. Also, on May 27, 1940, Myrtle assigned her insurance policy on the devised land to herself and Hughie and Estelene. Myrtle Hayes was recently widowed at the time of these transactions.

The deed was placed in an envelope which contained certain writing on it. Appellants contend that the writing was inadmissible because hearsay and unauthenticated and premise error on the admission of the envelope into evidence. We need not reach that contention for we find it unnecessary to consider the writing in disposing of the case.

The envelope was then placed in an escrow account at the Bank of Memphis until 1948. At that time Myrtle wanted to transfer the deed to the recently formed Farmers and Merchants Bank and asked Hughie for permission to do so. Hughie initially demurred but after an hour and a half or two hours of argument finally said, “[I]f it will make you happy, Mother, move it up to the Farmers and Merchants Bank.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.