New York Court of Appeals March 21, 1973 (Williams v. Town of Oyster Bay)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-03-1973

Chief Judge Fuld.

The plaintiffs, Catherine and Gene Williams, own property in a Residence D zoning district in the Village of Massapequa, Town of Oyster Bay. Unable to obtain a business use variance, they brought this suit against the town to have article VI of its Building Zone Ordinance, which governs Residence D uses, declared unconstitutional as applied to their property.

The plaintiffs’ land is located on the south side of Merrick Road, extending from Fox Boulevard on the west to Bay view Avenue on the east. The western half, the subject premises, is zoned (as indicated) “ Residence D,” the eastern half “Business F.” Outside of this business area, on which Mr. Williams has erected a number of small taxpayers, all of the property *80in the vicinity on both sides of Merrick Boad and in the neighboring side streets is zoned for residential use. On the north side of Merrick Boad, a number of the residences contain the offices of professionals — doctors, dentists and lawyers, all uses permitted in a Besidence D district until 1971 — and, in addition, a realty office and a pet clinic. Across the way on the southwest corner of Fox Boulevard and Merrick Boad is a gift shop. In addition to one-family dwellings, other authorized uses in Besidence D zones include two-family dwellings, churches, parks, libraries, museums, colleges, eleemosynary institutions and rooming or boarding houses, some of these requiring approval as a special exception by the town board or the board of appeals (Town of Oyster Bay Building Zone Ordinance, § 317).

On the corner of the plaintiffs’ residential property here involved is a residence formerly used as a realty office and now vacant. A witness testified on behalf of the defendant that Mr. Williams had refused his offer of $36,000 or his wife’s of $38,000 for it for residential use. The rest of the property between this house and the taxpayers is empty.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.