Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York March 5, 1973 (Velez v. Craine & Clarke Lumber Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-03-1973

Judgment of the Supreme Court, Kings County, entered November 29, 1971, reversed, on the law, without costs, and complaint dismissed. The findings of fact below are affirmed. Plaintiffs brought this action against the defendant lumber supply company to recover damages, on the theories of breach of warranty and negligence, for personal injuries sustained when a scaffolding plank broke under their weight and caused them to fall. At the close of the entire case at a separate trial on the issue of liability, the trial court dismissed the negligence causes of action and reserved decision on defendant’s motion to dismiss the causes of action for breach of warranty. The jury found for plaintiffs on the theory of breach of warranty and at the subsequent trial on the issue of damages a different jury awarded them substantial damages. John Valentine, the job superintendent of Julius Nasso Concrete Company, plaintiffs’ employer, testified that on January 27, 1970 he ordered a quantity of lumber from defendant by telephone, including 200 pieces of 2 by 9 scaffold planking, and that he specifically asked for scaffold planking. He had 20 years’ experience in the trade and had dealt with defendant for 15 or 16 years; this was the normal way he gave an order and was the standard procedure for ordering. He further testified that scaffold planking was a standard item 13 feet long, suitable for scaffolding, and should be number one grade &emdash; free from any imperfections that would affect the quality of the material. Defendant’s vice-president, who received the telephone order from Valentine, testified that the latter specifically asked for rough spruce planking without saying which of two available grades he wanted. This was a repeat of many orders he had received from Valentine for other jobs during the previous two or three months and Valentine did not mention scaffold planking or say what he was going to use it for.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.