Massachusetts Appeals Court March 1, 1973 (Greco v. Mayor of Revere)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-03-1973

Grant, J.

These two petitions for writs of mandamus seek to compel recognition of the petitioners as duly appointed and confirmed members of the licensing board of *136the city of Revere (G. L. c. 138, § 4, as amended through St. 1958, c. 803). The cases come to us on the pleadings, the trial judge’s consolidated findings, rulings and order for judgments dismissing the petitions, the petitioners’ appeals from that order, and a report of all the evidence. G. L. c. 213, § ID. Sherriff v. Mayor of Revere, 355 Mass. 133, 134.4

The sole issue to be decided is whether the appointments of the petitioners were validly confirmed under G. L. c. 138, § 4, in view of the provisions of § 2-12 of the ordinances of Revere5 and the provisions of certain of the rules of order of the city council.6

*137The facts may be summarized as follows. At 8:47 p.m. on the Monday evening, November 22,1971, all but two of the members of the city council convened at what everyone concedes was a “regular meeting” within the meaning of § 2-12 of the ordinances (fn. 5). It appears from the minutes of that meeting that following the transaction of certain business not here material a member of the council moved that “the City Council now stand adjourned to meet in regular session on Wednesday evening, November 24, 1971.” On a roll call vote (six in favor, three opposed and two still absent) it was “Ordered Adjourned.”

At 8:05 p.m. on Wednesday evening, November 24,1971, at what the minutes characterize as a “Regular meeting,” all but one of the members of the council were present in the council chamber and were called to order. The minutes of that gathering disclose that there was received and read a letter from the then mayor dated November 24,1971, which had been received by the city clerk earlier on that day and by which the then mayor appointed the two petitioners to fill vacancies on the licensing board.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.