Louisiana Court of Appeal November 16, 1973, No. 5490 (Brewer v. Delouise)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-11-1973

SAMUEL, Judge.

Plaintiff, a deputy sheriff, filed this suit against Mrs. Marguerite Delouise, her husband, and their automobile liability insurer for personal injuries (no special damages are alleged or sought) to his forearm and complications arising therefrom. The injuries were incurred while he was in the process of giving Mrs. Delouise a traffic citation. Defendants answered, denying negligence on the part of Mrs. Delouise, averring the sole cause of the injuries in suit was negligence on the part of plaintiff, and alternatively pleading contributory negligence. Following trial on the merits there was judgment in favor of plaintiff and against the defendants in the sum of $20,000. Defendants have appealed. Tn this court they contend the trial court erred in finding any negligence on their part. They further contend, alternatively, plaintiff was guilty of contributory negligence and, further alternatively, the amount awarded is excessive.

The incident occurred on May 23, 1969 at about 11:20 a. m. on Lake Avenue in the Parish of Jefferson where plaintiff was operating a traffic radar unit for the detection of speeding vehicles. Mrs. De-louise, who was driving a Volkswagen, was clocked at a speed of 33 miles per hour in a 20 mile speed zone. She was stopped by plaintiff and ordered to pull over to the side of the road, which she did. Lake Avenue is a two-way, two-lane roadway and the stopped car partially blocked one lane of traffic. The Volkswagen remained stationary while defendant wrote the ticket and handed the defendant driver the book for her signature. Mrs. Delouise affixed her signature and returned the book to the plaintiff who then tore out the citation. From this point there is conflict in the various versions of the incident.

Regarding the manner in which the accident happened, the record contains the testimony of four eyewitnesses: plaintiff; Mrs. Delouise; Mrs. C. B.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.