United States Court of Military Appeals June 29, 1973, No. 26,648 (United States v. Temperley)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-06-1973

OPINION OF THE COURT

Darden, Chief Judge:

The object of our review here is the use, in a trial for desertion, of the accused’s responses to questions about his identity without his having been warned of his rights to counsel and against self-incrimination in compliance with United States v Tempia, 16 USCMA 629, 37 CMR 249 (1967).

The responses in issue occurred against this background. Albert Sayers, an agent of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, specialized in looking for persons unlawfully absent from the military service. The accused absented himself without leave on August 27, 1967, and, in October 1967, the Department of the Navy sought the FBI’s assistance. In October 1971, FBI Headquarters notified its Los Angeles office of the receipt from the Los Angeles Police Department of the accused’s fingerprints under the name of John Charles Rose, with an address in Woodland Hills, California. After reviewing Rose’s police record and securing his picture from the Los An-geles County sheriff’s office, Agent Sayers and two other agents went to the address in Woodland Hills. At the scene, the three agents watched the home for more than an hour. During this time they saw a teen-age girl enter and leave the residence. Questioning her, they *384learned that her father was named John Rose, that he was at work, and that he should be driving home soon. As darkness approached, Agent Sayers and one of the other agents knocked on the door while the third agent remained in the car. A man answered the door.

Agent Sayers testified in the following manner about what then happened:

A: Well, when he opened the door, I said "Mr. Rose”. He said "Yes”. I identified myself by name and by official credentials, and in addition Mr. Fender identified himself. I then asked him "Mr. John Charles Rose”, and he said "Yes”. I told him the purpose of our call. By this time we were moving into the hallway of the house, just inside the door.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.