United States Court of Claims January 18, 1973, No. 787-71 (Young Associates, Inc. v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-01-1973
lead-opinion
Davis, Judge,
delivered the opinion of the court:
Plaintiff Young Associates, Inc. contracted in June 1964 with the National Park Service of ¡the Department of the Interior to do some construction work, including lighting and *440tile-lining, in a new road tunnel built in Rook Creek Park in Washington, near the National Zoological Park. The work was accepted as completed in November 198b, but the Government thereaf ter assessed liquidated damages at $100 per day for 144 days of unexcusable delay in completion, a total of $14,400. This sum was deducted from the amount due the contractor.
Young Associates appealed the imposition of liquidated damages to the Department of the Interior Board of Contract Appeals, which affirmed the contracting officer’s determination. I'BCA No. 557-4-66,67-2 BOA ¶ >6676; 69-1 BCA f 7419 (Dec. 1968). This action to review the administrative holding raises purely legal issues; the facts are not now disputed 1 and both sides have moved for summary judgment.
Plaintiff’s major challenge is that the board erred in ruling that the contract should be construed as containing a liquidated-damages provision (under which the contracting officer thought he was acting). It is agreed that liquidated damages could not be imposed unless authorized by the contract, and it is also common ground that a liquidated-damage provision was not mandatory for this type of contract but was optional at the election of the contracting officer. The basic question is whether such a requirement became part of this undertaking.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit