Richmond City Circuit Court April 20, 1973, Case No. 5264 (Colonial Williamsburg Foundation v. Johnson)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-04-1973

By JUDGE ALEX H. SANDS, JR.

This case is before the court upon demurrers filed on behalf of all defendants.

Basically, the gravamen of the plaintiff’s claim is that the defendants Wiley and Wilson undertook to construct a laundry for the plaintiff and the defendants Allen and Vickers furnished the material and also undertook the duty of supervision of the installation; that due to the water conditions at Williamsburg, the pipes employed in this project became corroded and had to be replaced with new pipes by the plaintiff. In a nutshell, the plaintiff’s contention is that it was the duty of all of the defendants to test and analyze the water in the area prior to installation of the equipment and that their failure to do so resulted in the pipes becoming unuseable.

The motion for judgment contains four separate counts. The first count charges breach of contract, the second breach of implied warranty of fitness, the third negligence and the fourth breach of implied warranty to do the job in a workmanlike manner.

Defendants Wiley & Wilson and Allen and Vickers have filed demurrers based upon misjoinder of causes of *511action and, in addition, Wiley & Wilson demurs upon the further ground that no one of the four counts state a cause of action as to this defendant.

Defendants say that count one sets up breach of contract, count three charges negligence and that counts two and four charge breach of implied warranties which sound in tort. Relying upon the rule which ordinarily prohibits the joining of charges of tort and contract in the same action, defendants say that the alleged existing misjoinder is demurable. That the general rule is as defendants contend is true beyond question. Daniels v. Truck Corporation, 205 Va. 579 (1964); Kavanaugh v. Donovan, 186 Va. 85 (1947).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.