Amherst County Circuit Court December 19, 1973 (Exxon, Inc. v. Worley)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-12-1973
By Judge Robert C. Goad
In this law action on two notes, the jury found for the defendant, Worley, on Exxon’s Motion for Judgment and for the plaintiff, Exxon, on Worley’s Counterclaim.
Exxon moved the Court to set aside the verdict as contrary to the law and the evidence in that the verdict awarded no amount to the plaintiff, there being no proper evidence upon which to base such a verdict, and on the further main ground that the Court erred in failing to instruct the jury that the plaintiff was entitled to the 18% attorney’s fee sued for in the Motion for Judgment. The two notes forming the basis for the suit of Exxon called for payment of attorney’s fees not exceeding 18%.
In a recent similar case, Humble v. Copley, 213 Va. 449 (1972), the Court said: “In a suit on a note, once the necessary signatures aré admitted or established, the holder is entitled to recover unless the defendant establishes a defense. The defendant has the burden of establishing his defense by a preponderance of the evidence.” In the case at bar, the two original notes sued on by Exxon were introduced in evidence, without objection, and the signatures of both defendants as makers of the notes were fully established and admitted. Therefore, the defendants had the burden of establishing their defense by a preponderance of the evidence. The Court is of the opinion, and so finds, that as a matter of law, the defendants did not carry this burden, with the minor exceptions hereinafter set forth.
Plaintiff’s Exhibit 3 shows a breakdown of the $4,617.02, being the balance claimed due on the notes by Exxon. Taking the large amounts on the Exhibit in order, the following was clearly estab*401lished by the evidence: the $1,200.00 was interest on the two notes; the $2,279.04 was for a load of gas or fuel delivered in January, 1968, which was first put on open account and then transferred to the note account; the $563.00 was for equipment bought by Worley; the $2,545.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit