District Court, D. South Carolina October 8, 1973, Civ. A. No. 73-572 (La-Z-Boy Chair Co. v. Hinds)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-10-1973

ORDER

HEMPHILL, District Judge.

Plaintiff moves for summary judgment pursuant to Rule 56 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, insisting that no genuine issue of fact exists as a matter of law. The original complaint alleges the sale of merchandise to defendant in the amount of Fifty Thousand Seventy-Eight and 39/100 ($50,078.39) Dollars; attached to the complaint is a statement of account. The answer of the defendant alleges that he returned ninety (90) chairs and the acceptance by the plaintiff of these ninety (90) chairs, previously shipped to the defendant by the plaintiff, was in accord and satisfaction of the debt. Defendant’s answer further alleges valuable consideration by virtue of the depletion of defendant’s stock in trade below operational levels, as a result of the return of the chairs, and that defendant’s business was closed.1

In response to discovery defendant admitted that prior to the commencement of the delivery of the ninety (90) chairs *34to the plaintiff, which took place on or about February 9, 1973, defendant was indebted to the plaintiff in the amount of Sixty Thousand and 00/100 ($60,000.-00) Dollars. After a hearing before this court on October 4, 1973, on the motion, defendant’s counsel conceded that there was no dispute as to the indebtedness of defendant to plaintiff prior to the return of the chairs in question. Discovery further produced an admission by the defendant that the chairs were worth about Ten Thousand ($10,000.00) Dollars.2 Further, in the testimony from the deposition referred to in footnote 2, we find the following.3

The following testimony from the deposition of Mr. Hinds is that upon which defendant’s counsel apparently basis his defense of accord and satisfaction:

(Testimony of Mr. Hinds referring to Mr. Ralph Droege, a salesman for the plaintiff at page 10, line 22, of the deposition.)

(Mr. Hinds): And then he [Mr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.