Court of Customs and Patent Appeals June 21, 1973, Patent Appeal No. 9000 (In re Glass)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-06-1973
MARKEY, Chief Judge.
This is an appeal from the decision of the Patent Office Board of Appeals sustaining the rejection of claims 12-19 under 35 U.S.C. § 103 of appellant’s application serial No. 670,335, filed September 25, 1967, for “Method of Forming a Boat Rail and the Like.” We affirm.
The Invention
The invention is clear from claim 12:
12. A method of continuously forming rails for use on boat hulls, comprising the steps of feeding a molten material which does not readily accept adhesives to an extruding die, feeding an adhesive belt into said die, said belt including an impermeable backing layer which readily accepts adhesive, an adhesive layer attached to the backing layer, and a removable cover sheet covering the adhesive layer, bonding one side only of the backing layer to said material, extruding said material and backing layer from said die as a molding form, cutting the molded form into rails, removing the cover sheet, and mounting the rails onto a boat hull by pressing the adhesive layer against the hull.
The Rejection
As presented here, the rejection is based on a French patent to Schock, number 1,411,614 (Schock’s British patent 1,076,033 by stipulation employed as the translation), Garling 3,253,971 and Egerton 1,352,739. Other patents were referred to in prosecution and before the board. Appellant points to variances in the reference combinations cited as prosecution progressed and to a change in emphasis from Garling to the French patent between the final rejection and the Answer of the examiner. Appellant also professes an inability to understand the final rejection and that he still awaits adequate clarification and citation of authority in support of the rejection.
*1051The French patent discloses the extrusion molding of a plastic strip together with a covering strip, which may be fabric, foil, metal or the like.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit