Court of Customs and Patent Appeals August 23, 1973, Patent Appeal No. 8591 (Rion v. Ault)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-08-1973

ON REHEARING

RICH, Judge.

Our original opinion of February 24, 1972, was published at 455 F.2d 570. We there reversed the decision of the Board of Patent Interferences awarding priority to Ault et al. (Ault) and remanded because we found “there is no interference in fact.” Ault petitioned for rehearing and Rion et al. (Rion) opposed. The Patent Office Solicitor called our attention to the fact that under the Patent Office Rules a holding of no interference in fact is not appropriate under the facts of this case and that the case of Brailsford v. Lavet, 50 CCPA 1367, 318 F.2d 942 (1963), which we had cited in support of the contrary proposition, was distinguishable on its facts. We now agree with this Patent Office position. We granted rehearing on November 9, 1972, and the ease was rebriefed at our request and reargued on February 5, 1973.

We have fully reconsidered the case, concluding that the reasoning of and result reached in our prior opinion was erroneous. Our opinion of February 24, 1972, is hereby withdrawn and replaced by the following opinion. The decision announced therein is vacated.

This appeal is from the decision of the Board of Patent Interferences awarding priority of invention to Ault, the senior party, on the ground that Rion’s evidence failed to establish either a conception or reduction to practice prior to Ault’s filing date. The board also held, contrary to Rion’s contentions, that Ault had the right to make the counts and, in connection with this holding, ruled that the definition placed on the counts by the Primary Examiner, who drafted them and suggested them to both parties, is controlling.

This appeal by Rion does not question the board’s holding that Rion did not overcome Ault’s record date and, therefore, so far as priority in time is concerned, Ault must be accepted as the first inventor of whatever he invented. This appeal, as briefed and argued by Rion, essentially raises only the question of Ault’s right to make the counts.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.