Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit July 16, 1973, Nos. 72-1867 to 72-1869 (Farha v. Commissioner)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-07-1973

DOYLE, Circuit Judge.

The present appeal involves an income tax controversy in which § 453 of the Internal Revenue Code of 19541 is in question and, particularly, the limitation on the installment method of reporting income which requires that in the taxable year the sale or disposition of the payments do not exceed 30 percent of the selling price.

In the case at bar there was a sale of stock in a corporation which was engaged in the buying, processing and selling of meat and food products, together with a partnership which owned the land and buildings, trademarks and trade names. The question is whether the corporation and the partnership can be treated as a single business unit so that the 30 percent limit can be related to the total selling price. The Tax Court ruled that it could not, holding that business was conducted through separate entities and that they could not be brought together in order to serve a purpose favorable to the taxpayers.2

*20The businesses here in question were conducted by the Farha family prior to August 19, 1967. There was a corporation called Hereford Heaven Brands, Inc. It was engaged in the buying, processing and selling pf meat and food products. The shareholders were Chick M. Farha, Woodrow W. Farha, Sue M. Farha and Fred M. Farha. Fred is not a party to this appeal.

The partnership was called Hereford Brands Company. It owned the land and buildings' and, as indicated above, the trademarks and trade names. On the mentioned date (August 19, 1967), the Farhas sold the entire business to George A. Hormel & Company. In connection with this sale there were three separate written agreements which were all made at the same time.

The first of these provided for the sale of all the partnership assets. The total of this was $855,000. In 1967, Chick M. Farha received $32,977.50 out of a total of $375,943.50; Sue M. Farha received $8,242.50 out of a total of $93,964.50; and Woodrow W. Farha received $32,977.50 out of a total of $375,943.50.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.