Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania June 19, 1974, Appeal, 1063 C.D. 1973 (Berger v. Borough of Bethel Park)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-06-1974
Opinion by
Judge Wilkinson,
In December, 1972, appellant acquired all of the personal property of a business, a figure improvement salon, in the Borough of Bethel Park. The prior business had been granted a certificate of occupancy for such a salon in December, 1970.
1
In February, 1973, appellant became the lessee of the premises occupied by the prior business and began operating what he calls a “health club” and what the Borough calls a “massage parlor.” The Borough, in May, 1973, sought an injunction against appellant alleging that appellant’s operation of a business without a building permit and a certificate of occupancy was a violation of the Borough’s zoning code. Furthermore, the business was
*15
alleged to be a massage parlor, such a business not being a permitted use.
The Chancellor issued a preliminary injunction and after two hearings, entered a final decree on July 12, 1973, making the injunction permanent. The Chancellor made two specific findings:
“1. Since the original certificate of occupancy was issued on December 11, 1970, there have been sufficient alterations and additions to the premises known as 2405 South Park Road, Bethel Park, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania, as defined in the Borough’s ordinances so as to require the application and subsequent issuance of new building and occupancy permits before
any
business may lawfully commence operations at said premises; and (emphasis in original)
“2. The intended business of defendant [appellant here] which would require its female employees, while topless, to administer massages to male customers is not considered a health club which is a “permitted use” pursuant to the C-2 Borough classification.”
This appeal followed.
Initially, we must note that our scope of review in this equity case is restricted. As noted by President Judge Bowman in
Ross v. Philadelphia Federation of Teachers,
8 Pa. Commonwealth Ct. 204, 213, 301 A.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit