Court of Appeals for the First Circuit March 14, 1974, 73-1308 (Keith Walker, D/B/A Homefinder's v. Providence Journal Company)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-03-1974

LEVIN H. CAMPBELL, Circuit Judge.

Homefinders of America, Inc. (Home-finders), a corporation with a primary place of business in Denver, Colorado, is engaged in the business of licensing or franchising independent businessmen in various states and Canada to use the Homefinders trademark and its distinctive method of providing information about housing vacancies. Keith Walker, the plaintiff, was the franchisee for Rhode Island.

Walker brought suit in the district court on March 5, 1973, alleging that the Providence Journal Co. (Journal), publisher of the only statewide morning and evening newspapers (which held at least two-thirds of all newspaper readership in the state) had violated the antitrust laws, 15 U.S.C. §§ 1 and 2, by attempting to fix the price Walker could charge for his service,

1

by refusing to deal with him, and by attempting to monopolize the market in rental information services by eliminating competitors to the classified advertising section of the papers. Walker sought preliminary and permanent injunctive relief and treble damages. This appeal is from the court’s denial, after hearing, of a preliminary injunction upon the ground that there was no proper plaintiff before the court. We affirm, but for different reasons.

Walker commenced business in Rhode Island during 1972. Following the Homefinders format he sold for $20 a

*84

“policy” entitling its holder to use for a period of one year the services of Home-finders operations throughout the United States. A policy holder was granted access to listings of vacancies classified according to the requirements of different clients; the listings were in cata-logues permitting selection by location, price range, landlords’ willingness to take children, pets, etc. The office would supply this listing information upon telephoned or personal inquiry.

Walker culled many but not all his listings from classified newspaper ads. In turn Walker advertised his service in newspapers, primarily those of the Journal.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.