Tennessee Supreme Court November 12, 1974 (Lindsey v. Fowler)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-11-1974

OPINION

HENRY, Justice.

This is an appeal from the action of the Chancery Court of Davidson County in affirming an order of the Public Service Commission dismissing the application of appellant for a certificate of convenience and necessity to transport petroleum products between all points in Memphis and points within its commercial zone.

*89We do not reach the merits of this controversy since the record before this Court is inadequate to permit appellate review.

This Court is reluctant to decline to entertain any appeal on the basis of technicalities and makes every effort to rescue the record and reach a decision on the merits.

The record in this case, however, is beyond the reach of the life-line.

The record reflects that the Bill of Exceptions was not timely filed and that all respondents, pursuant to Sec. 27-318, T.C. A. moved the Chancellor to dismiss the appeal.

The Chancellor sustained the motions, holding that the Bill of Exceptions was not timely filed; that petitioner did not comply with the requirements of Sec. 27-110, T.C. A., and “thus, no Bill of Exceptions has been filed in this cause.”

The Chancellor, in the exercise of his discretion, declined to dismiss the appeal but held that “there being no Bill of Exceptions filed in this cause, any appeal taken by petitioner must stand on the technical record alone.” This holding by the Chancellor is but declaratory of the consistent holdings of the appellate courts of this State.

The tendered Bill of Exceptions is not made a part of the record on appeal and this Court’s knowledge of the contents thereof is limited to the technical record before the Court.

It is, however, apparent and significant that petitioner proceeded upon the assumption that a Bill of Exceptions was necessary.

Our review of this case is limited to the technical record.

We are presented with a large, expandable envelope, with two pasters on the outside.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.