Supreme Judicial Court of Maine January 28, 1975 (Wright v. Superintending Sch. Com., City of Portland)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-01-1975

combined-opinion

331 A.2d 640 (1975) Stanley W. WRIGHT, Jr. v. SUPERINTENDING SCHOOL COMMITTEE, CITY OF PORTLAND, and City of Portland. Supreme Judicial Court of Maine. January 28, 1975. *641 Nixon & Corson by David J. Corson, Yarmouth, for plaintiff. Charles A. Lane, Portland, for defendant. Before DUFRESNE, C. J., and WEATHERBEE, POMEROY, WERNICK, ARCHIBALD and DELAHANTY, JJ. POMEROY, Justice. Appellant was a tenured teacher in the public school system of the City of Portland, having had 12 years service. At all times material hereto he was also a federally licensed gunsmith and the holder of a concealed weapons permit. It is the fact he was attempting to perform the functions of a gunsmith during the same time he was charged with performing the duties of a teacher that brought this law suit into being. This appeal is from the denial of a complaint filed in the Superior Court pursuant to the provisions of Rule 80B, M.R.Civ.P., which attacks the action of the Superintending School Committee of the City of Portland in dismissing appellant from his position as a teacher because of the Committee's conclusion he was "unfit" to teach in the Portland school system. *642 Purported authority for the Committee's action is Title 20 M.R.S.A. 473(4) which reads in material part: "After investigation, due notice of hearing, and hearing thereon, they shall dismiss any teacher, although having the requisite certificate, who proves unfit to teach or whose service they deem unprofitable to the school;...." The Justice below concluded there was no contested issue as to the facts. Rather he saw the sole issue as "whether the facts justify a finding of `unfitness' and the punishment of dismissal." To use his words, "... the question is whether the Court, under these circumstances can second-guess the statutorily and constitutionally charged Superintending School Committee in the regular exercise of the prerogatives vested in it under the laws of this State.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.